The List

3 Bob Dylan Songs That Fans Hate (But I Happen To Love)

Bob Dylan has released some of the greatest songs of the 20th century. But heโ€™s only human, like any other musician. Heโ€™s dropped a few songs over the years that never really resonated with listeners, even after they had a few years to really sit with them. When it comes to the following Bob Dylan songs that fans hate, I can at least love aspects of them that make them unique. Letโ€™s take a look!

โ€œWiggle Wiggleโ€ from โ€˜Under The Red Skyโ€™ (1990)

Alright, I get why people really hate this song. Itโ€™s about as far from a Bob Dylan classic as it gets. Between Slash on guitar (who sounds great, of course, but not exactly what one would expect on a Dylan track) and thoseโ€ฆ questionable lyrics that are too vulgar to post here, this song is seen as a stain on an already controversial album. Personally, I love that you can tell Dylan had fun with this one and wasnโ€™t taking himself too seriously. Still, listeners made their opinions known in the years since this song dropped.

Videos by American Songwriter

โ€œI have to admit, I admire his bravery for including a line like โ€˜wiggle ’til you vomit fire,โ€™โ€ said one commenter.

โ€œIf Dog Runs Freeโ€ from โ€˜New Morningโ€™ (1970)

Personally, I enjoy how experimental this song is. And we all know that every time Bob Dylan got experimental, there was always someone there to criticize his choices. The jazziness of this song is easygoing and pleasant enough, and the choice to include Al Kooper on piano and scat-singer Maeretha Stewart was a wise one. Yet, some people didnโ€™t love this song, including a few YouTube commenters who didnโ€™t exactly love the backing vocals or the introduction. 

โ€œListen to the โ€˜blues alarmโ€™ on an iPhone or iPad then listen to this intro,โ€ said one commenter. โ€œI just canโ€™t.โ€

โ€œProperty Of Jesusโ€ from โ€˜Shot Of Loveโ€™ (1981)

Not many people love Bob Dylanโ€™s born-again Christian era. I get it. Shot Of Love was a bit of a controversial album. However, during that era, Dylan really knew how to put his own spin on gospel in a musically powerful way. I think โ€œProperty Of Jesusโ€ is one of the best songs off of Shot Of Love from a musical perspective. And yet, it makes it to this list of songs by Bob Dylan that fans hate for a reason. While youโ€™ll find many fans of Christian music praising this song, others have found themselves confused over their feelings toward it.

โ€œI actually love this song,โ€ said Josh of Setlist Kitchen. โ€œ In fact, it rocks. But it’s also so bad! It was at the height of Bob’s holier than thou Born-Again conversion.โ€

Photo by Fin Costello/Redferns