The List

Percy Sledge Recorded His Only No. 1 Hit After His Girlfriend Moved Away

In 1966, Percy Sledge released โ€œWhen A Man Loves A Womanโ€. The song, his first single, is the title track of Sledgeโ€™s freshman album. It was written by Calvin Lewis and Andrew Wright, who played music with Sledge.

Sledge isn’t credited as a writer on โ€œWhen A Man Loves A Womanโ€. But the song is very autobiographical for him, based on a heartbreak he endured. “When A Man Loves A Woman” says in part, โ€œWell, this man loves you, woman / I gave you everything I had / Tryin’ to hold on to your heartless love / Baby, please don’t treat me bad.” 

Videos by American Songwriter

Sledge reportedly recorded this song when he was upset about his longtime girlfriend, who left him to become a model in Los Angeles.

“I didn’t have any money to go after her,” Sledge says. “So there was nothing I could do to try and get her back.” But he was so distraught about losing her that when he was playing a gig with Lewis and Wright, he asked them to play something sad. Sledge spilled his broken heart for several minutes, creating what became “When A Man Loves A Woman”.

The Writing of “When A Man Loves A Woman” by Percy Sledge

It’s interesting that Sledge is not listed as a writer on โ€œWhen A Man Loves A Womanโ€. Still, he later does say he was part of the writing process.

“When I wrote the song at first, it was called โ€˜Why Did You Leave Me Baby’,” Sledge recounts. “And I changed it from that to โ€˜When A Man Loves A Womanโ€™. I just reversed it.”

“When A Man Loves A Woman” not only became a big hit for Sledge, but it was also recorded by numerous other artists, including Michael Bolton. Bolton’s version, out in 1991, became a No. 1 hit for him as well. Lewis admits he and Wright had no idea that the song would become so successful.

โ€œItโ€™s kind of mind-boggling to me that the song is still doing what itโ€™s doing,โ€ Lewis tells American Songwriter. โ€œAt the time we wrote it, it didnโ€™t hit me what having an ‘A’ side release meant until the song was well on its way to number one.โ€

Decades later, Lewis still remembers hearing Sledge sing their song on the radio for the first time.

โ€œIt was just incredible,โ€ he says. โ€œThere was just this feeling that went all the way through me. But I never thought it would last this long.โ€

Photo by Gilles Petard/Redferns